Every game of the reign
| Belt game | Date | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Mar 7, 1874 | Scotland beat England 2–1 (Friendly) | Title change |
| 4 | Mar 6, 1875 | Scotland and England tied 2–2 (Friendly) | Tie · defense |
| 5 | Mar 4, 1876 | Scotland beat England 3–0 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 6 | Mar 25, 1876 | Scotland beat Wales 4–0 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 7 | Mar 3, 1877 | Scotland beat England 3–1 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 8 | Mar 5, 1877 | Scotland beat Wales 2–0 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 9 | Mar 2, 1878 | Scotland beat England 7–2 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 10 | Mar 23, 1878 | Scotland beat Wales 9–0 (Friendly) | Defense |
| 11 | Apr 5, 1879 | England beat Scotland 5–4 (Friendly) | Title change |