The English Football Belt · rivalry
Everton vs. Sheffield United
18Belt meetings
5Everton wins
8Sheffield Utd wins
6Title changes
Everton and Sheffield United have met 18 times with the Premier League belt on the line, from February 26, 1895 to October 12, 1974. The belt changed hands in 6 of those games. Sheffield United lead the belt series 8–5, with 5 ties.
| Belt game | Date | Result | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 185 | Feb 26, 1895 | Sheffield United beat Everton 4–2 | Title change |
| 257 | Oct 30, 1897 | Sheffield United beat Everton 4–1 | Defense |
| 382 | Oct 5, 1901 | Everton beat Sheffield United 2–1 | Defense |
| 401 | Feb 1, 1902 | Sheffield United and Everton tied 0–0 | Tie · defense |
| 519 | Oct 7, 1905 | Sheffield United beat Everton 3–2 | Title change |
| 611 | Feb 15, 1908 | Sheffield United beat Everton 2–0 | Title change |
| 664 | Oct 16, 1909 | Sheffield United beat Everton 2–1 | Defense |
| 702 | Oct 15, 1910 | Everton beat Sheffield United 1–0 | Defense |
| 757 | Feb 10, 1912 | Everton beat Sheffield United 3–2 | Defense |
| 831 | Feb 14, 1914 | Everton beat Sheffield United 5–0 | Title change |
| 1,756 | Apr 19, 1947 | Sheffield United beat Everton 2–0 | Title change |
| 1,794 | Mar 20, 1948 | Sheffield United beat Everton 2–1 | Defense |
| 2,383 | Mar 14, 1962 | Everton and Sheffield United tied 1–1 | Tie · defense |
| 2,468 | Feb 22, 1964 | Everton and Sheffield United tied 0–0 | Tie · defense |
| 2,486 | Sep 12, 1964 | Sheffield United and Everton tied 1–1 | Tie · defense |
| 2,591 | Jan 14, 1967 | Everton beat Sheffield United 4–1 | Title change |
| 2,774 | Aug 21, 1971 | Sheffield United beat Everton 1–0 | Defense |
| 2,914 | Oct 12, 1974 | Everton and Sheffield United tied 2–2 | Tie · defense |