| 11,700 | Jun 28, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Kansas City Athletics 8–0 | Defense |
| 11,699 | Jun 27, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Kansas City Athletics 10–3 | Defense |
| 11,698 | Jun 26, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Chicago White Sox 4–3 | Defense |
| 11,697 | Jun 24, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Chicago White Sox 6–2 | Title change |
| 11,696 | Jun 23, 1958 | Chicago White Sox beat New York Yankees 2–0 | Title change |
| 11,695 | Jun 22, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Detroit Tigers 15–0 | Title change |
| 11,694 | Jun 21, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat New York Yankees 1–0 | Defense |
| 11,693 | Jun 20, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat New York Yankees 7–1 | Title change |
| 11,692 | Jun 19, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Cleveland Indians 9–3 | Defense |
| 11,691 | Jun 18, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Cleveland Indians 3–2 | Defense |
| 11,690 | Jun 17, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Cleveland Indians 4–0 | Title change |
| 11,689 | Jun 15, 1958 | Cleveland Indians beat Washington Senators 4–2 | Defense |
| 11,688 | Jun 15, 1958 | Cleveland Indians beat Washington Senators 5–3 | Defense |
| 11,687 | Jun 14, 1958 | Cleveland Indians beat Washington Senators 10–2 | Defense |
| 11,686 | Jun 13, 1958 | Cleveland Indians beat Washington Senators 10–1 | Title change |
| 11,685 | Jun 12, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Chicago White Sox 6–5 | Defense |
| 11,684 | Jun 11, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Chicago White Sox 5–2 | Defense |
| 11,683 | Jun 10, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Chicago White Sox 5–2 | Title change |
| 11,682 | Jun 10, 1958 | Chicago White Sox beat Washington Senators 5–4 | Title change |
| 11,681 | Jun 8, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Detroit Tigers 4–3 | Defense |
| 11,680 | Jun 7, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Detroit Tigers 4–3 | Title change |
| 11,679 | Jun 6, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Washington Senators 11–2 | Defense |
| 11,678 | Jun 5, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Baltimore Orioles 6–3 | Title change |
| 11,677 | Jun 4, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Detroit Tigers 6–4 | Defense |
| 11,676 | Jun 3, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Detroit Tigers 2–0 | Title change |
| 11,675 | May 31, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Chicago White Sox 3–0 | Title change |
| 11,674 | May 30, 1958 | Chicago White Sox beat Detroit Tigers 4–2 | Defense |
| 11,673 | May 30, 1958 | Chicago White Sox beat Detroit Tigers 6–5 | Title change |
| 11,672 | May 28, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Boston Red Sox 4–2 | Defense |
| 11,671 | May 27, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Boston Red Sox 3–2 | Defense |
| 11,670 | May 25, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Washington Senators 6–3 | Defense |
| 11,669 | May 25, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat Washington Senators 7–2 | Defense |
| 11,668 | May 24, 1958 | Detroit Tigers beat New York Yankees 3–2 | Title change |
| 11,667 | May 23, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Detroit Tigers 8–1 | Defense |
| 11,666 | May 22, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Detroit Tigers 5–4 | Defense |
| 11,665 | May 21, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Chicago White Sox 5–2 | Defense |
| 11,664 | May 20, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Chicago White Sox 5–1 | Defense |
| 11,663 | May 18, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 3–0 | Defense |
| 11,662 | May 18, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 5–2 | Defense |
| 11,661 | May 17, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 6–5 | Defense |
| 11,660 | May 16, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 7–2 | Defense |
| 11,659 | May 14, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 1–0 | Defense |
| 11,658 | May 13, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 3–0 | Title change |
| 11,657 | May 11, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Boston Red Sox 4–0 | Defense |
| 11,656 | May 11, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Boston Red Sox 3–2 | Defense |
| 11,655 | May 10, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Boston Red Sox 5–2 | Title change |
| 11,654 | May 9, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Baltimore Orioles 13–5 | Defense |
| 11,653 | May 6, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Chicago White Sox 7–5 | Defense |
| 11,652 | May 5, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Cleveland Indians 8–5 | Defense |
| 11,651 | May 4, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Cleveland Indians 2–1 | Title change |
| 11,650 | May 4, 1958 | Cleveland Indians beat Boston Red Sox 2–1 | Title change |
| 11,649 | May 2, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Detroit Tigers 6–0 | Defense |
| 11,648 | May 1, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Kansas City Athletics 7–6 | Title change |
| 11,647 | Apr 30, 1958 | Kansas City Athletics beat Boston Red Sox 11–4 | Title change |
| 11,646 | Apr 27, 1958 | Boston Red Sox beat Washington Senators 7–5 | Title change |
| 11,645 | Apr 26, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Boston Red Sox 7–5 | Defense |
| 11,644 | Apr 25, 1958 | Washington Senators beat Boston Red Sox 2–0 | Defense |
| 11,643 | Apr 23, 1958 | Washington Senators beat New York Yankees 5–4 | Title change |
| 11,642 | Apr 22, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Boston Red Sox 12–7 | Defense |
| 11,641 | Apr 21, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Boston Red Sox 4–1 | Defense |
| 11,640 | Apr 20, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 7–0 | Defense |
| 11,639 | Apr 19, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 4–3 | Defense |
| 11,638 | Apr 18, 1958 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 3–1 | Title change |
| 11,637 | Apr 17, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Washington Senators 4–0 | Defense |
| 11,636 | Apr 15, 1958 | Baltimore Orioles beat Washington Senators 6–1 | Defense |
| 11,635 | Sep 29, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat Washington Senators 7–3 | Defense |
| 11,634 | Sep 28, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat Washington Senators 9–1 | Defense |
| 11,633 | Sep 27, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat Washington Senators 7–3 | Defense |
| 11,632 | Sep 25, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat New York Yankees 4–2 | Title change |
| 11,631 | Sep 25, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 5–1 | Defense |
| 11,630 | Sep 22, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Boston Red Sox 5–1 | Title change |
| 11,629 | Sep 21, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat New York Yankees 8–3 | Title change |
| 11,628 | Sep 20, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Boston Red Sox 7–4 | Defense |
| 11,627 | Sep 18, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Detroit Tigers 4–3 | Defense |
| 11,626 | Sep 17, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Detroit Tigers 7–1 | Title change |
| 11,625 | Sep 15, 1957 | Detroit Tigers beat Boston Red Sox 4–3 | Defense |
| 11,624 | Sep 15, 1957 | Detroit Tigers beat Boston Red Sox 7–1 | Title change |
| 11,623 | Sep 14, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat Cleveland Indians 13–10 | Title change |
| 11,622 | Sep 13, 1957 | Cleveland Indians beat Boston Red Sox 16–3 | Defense |
| 11,621 | Sep 11, 1957 | Cleveland Indians beat New York Yankees 4–1 | Title change |
| 11,620 | Sep 11, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Cleveland Indians 5–0 | Defense |
| 11,619 | Sep 8, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 5–2 | Defense |
| 11,618 | Sep 7, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Washington Senators 4–1 | Title change |
| 11,617 | Sep 6, 1957 | Washington Senators beat New York Yankees 4–3 | Title change |
| 11,616 | Sep 5, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Boston Red Sox 5–2 | Title change |
| 11,615 | Sep 4, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat New York Yankees 7–5 | Title change |
| 11,614 | Sep 3, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Baltimore Orioles 2–0 | Title change |
| 11,613 | Sep 2, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat New York Yankees 6–1 | Defense |
| 11,612 | Sep 2, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat New York Yankees 8–7 | Defense |
| 11,611 | Sep 1, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat Boston Red Sox 2–1 | Defense |
| 11,610 | Aug 31, 1957 | Baltimore Orioles beat Boston Red Sox 4–1 | Title change |
| 11,609 | Aug 30, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat Baltimore Orioles 8–1 | Defense |
| 11,608 | Aug 29, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat Detroit Tigers 6–1 | Defense |
| 11,607 | Aug 28, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat Detroit Tigers 1–0 | Defense |
| 11,606 | Aug 27, 1957 | Boston Red Sox beat Detroit Tigers 7–5 | Title change |
| 11,605 | Aug 26, 1957 | Detroit Tigers beat New York Yankees 5–2 | Defense |
| 11,604 | Aug 25, 1957 | Detroit Tigers beat New York Yankees 7–2 | Title change |
| 11,603 | Aug 24, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Cleveland Indians 10–4 | Title change |
| 11,602 | Aug 23, 1957 | Cleveland Indians beat New York Yankees 5–4 | Title change |
| 11,601 | Aug 22, 1957 | New York Yankees beat Kansas City Athletics 11–4 | Title change |