| Cleveland Guardians vs. Chicago White Sox | 360 | 189–170–1 | 175 | 2019 |
| Cleveland Guardians vs. Detroit Tigers | 352 | 180–171–1 | 171 | 2025 |
| Chicago White Sox vs. New York Yankees | 346 | 141–205 | 167 | 2026 |
| Cleveland Guardians vs. Minnesota Twins | 338 | 179–159 | 166 | 2020 |
| Chicago White Sox vs. Detroit Tigers | 336 | 172–162–2 | 156 | 2026 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Detroit Tigers | 330 | 161–166–3 | 153 | 2026 |
| Athletics vs. New York Yankees | 324 | 129–193–2 | 149 | 2026 |
| Detroit Tigers vs. Minnesota Twins | 321 | 168–152–1 | 162 | 2021 |
| Cleveland Guardians vs. New York Yankees | 320 | 141–178–1 | 151 | 2026 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Cleveland Guardians | 316 | 145–169–2 | 140 | 2019 |
| Detroit Tigers vs. New York Yankees | 308 | 147–161 | 161 | 2026 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees | 307 | 134–172–1 | 160 | 2026 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Boston Red Sox | 303 | 144–156–3 | 146 | 2017 |
| Chicago White Sox vs. Minnesota Twins | 299 | 149–147–3 | 129 | 2020 |
| Athletics vs. Detroit Tigers | 296 | 135–159–2 | 145 | 2021 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Cleveland Guardians | 293 | 115–176–2 | 137 | 2015 |
| Athletics vs. Cleveland Guardians | 292 | 137–155 | 135 | 2009 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Chicago White Sox | 292 | 139–151–2 | 141 | 2025 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. New York Yankees | 290 | 112–176–2 | 117 | 2023 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. San Francisco Giants | 289 | 144–140–5 | 134 | 2018 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Chicago Cubs | 285 | 132–151–2 | 114 | 2026 |
| Athletics vs. Chicago White Sox | 276 | 134–141–1 | 142 | 2022 |
| Minnesota Twins vs. New York Yankees | 275 | 107–165–3 | 121 | 2026 |
| Athletics vs. Minnesota Twins | 270 | 133–136–1 | 136 | 2021 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Chicago White Sox | 269 | 134–133–2 | 125 | 2012 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 268 | 134–133–1 | 126 | 2015 |
| Philadelphia Phillies vs. San Francisco Giants | 263 | 111–147–5 | 112 | 2022 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. San Francisco Giants | 259 | 126–128–5 | 122 | 2024 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 253 | 141–112 | 122 | 2008 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Detroit Tigers | 247 | 117–129–1 | 124 | 2013 |
| Athletics vs. Boston Red Sox | 241 | 121–120 | 101 | 2023 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. San Francisco Giants | 236 | 112–121–3 | 109 | 2024 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 235 | 115–117–3 | 107 | 2023 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 228 | 126–98–4 | 112 | 2025 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Minnesota Twins | 225 | 106–119 | 105 | 2010 |
| Philadelphia Phillies vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 224 | 108–116 | 107 | 2022 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Minnesota Twins | 220 | 113–107 | 108 | 2026 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 214 | 116–94–4 | 101 | 2018 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates vs. San Francisco Giants | 213 | 107–103–3 | 106 | 2024 |
| San Francisco Giants vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 210 | 117–91–2 | 95 | 2022 |
| Athletics vs. Baltimore Orioles | 208 | 112–96 | 91 | 2024 |
| Philadelphia Phillies vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 203 | 92–110–1 | 83 | 1998 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Los Angeles Dodgers | 203 | 91–109–3 | 110 | 2026 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 200 | 94–104–2 | 99 | 2017 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 195 | 103–90–2 | 86 | 2017 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Los Angeles Dodgers | 191 | 94–97 | 96 | 2008 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Cincinnati Reds | 189 | 105–81–3 | 92 | 2025 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. Los Angeles Dodgers | 185 | 78–107 | 92 | 2025 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. San Francisco Giants | 184 | 84–100 | 94 | 2022 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 182 | 89–92–1 | 84 | 2026 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 182 | 96–83–3 | 94 | 1993 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 181 | 85–94–2 | 84 | 2026 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 169 | 75–93–1 | 84 | 2025 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 165 | 78–86–1 | 86 | 2024 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Cincinnati Reds | 163 | 78–84–1 | 75 | 2024 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 151 | 76–74–1 | 72 | 2022 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Washington Nationals | 102 | 57–45 | 44 | 2026 |
| New York Mets vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 100 | 44–56 | 50 | 2017 |
| Detroit Tigers vs. Los Angeles Angels | 96 | 53–43 | 43 | 2012 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Washington Nationals | 95 | 41–53–1 | 40 | 2011 |
| New York Mets vs. Washington Nationals | 93 | 40–53 | 53 | 2025 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Los Angeles Angels | 89 | 44–44–1 | 44 | 2019 |
| Philadelphia Phillies vs. Washington Nationals | 89 | 44–45 | 44 | 2022 |
| Boston Red Sox vs. Toronto Blue Jays | 86 | 45–41 | 34 | 2025 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. New York Mets | 85 | 44–41 | 41 | 2026 |
| Athletics vs. Texas Rangers | 84 | 48–36 | 42 | 2023 |
| New York Mets vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 84 | 45–39 | 36 | 2022 |
| Chicago White Sox vs. Los Angeles Angels | 83 | 44–39 | 41 | 2025 |
| Cleveland Guardians vs. Los Angeles Angels | 80 | 43–37 | 31 | 2019 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. New York Mets | 80 | 41–38–1 | 44 | 2015 |
| Houston Astros vs. San Francisco Giants | 79 | 38–41 | 38 | 2018 |
| Cincinnati Reds vs. New York Mets | 78 | 39–39 | 39 | 2024 |
| Houston Astros vs. St. Louis Cardinals | 78 | 34–43–1 | 36 | 2016 |
| Philadelphia Phillies vs. San Diego Padres | 77 | 51–26 | 42 | 2022 |
| St. Louis Cardinals vs. Washington Nationals | 77 | 42–35 | 38 | 2018 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. San Diego Padres | 76 | 48–28 | 35 | 2025 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Washington Nationals | 75 | 38–37 | 37 | 2026 |
| Los Angeles Angels vs. New York Yankees | 73 | 28–45 | 41 | 2023 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Houston Astros | 73 | 36–37 | 38 | 2021 |
| San Diego Padres vs. San Francisco Giants | 72 | 41–31 | 40 | 2024 |
| Los Angeles Angels vs. Minnesota Twins | 71 | 45–26 | 37 | 2026 |
| Detroit Tigers vs. Texas Rangers | 69 | 38–31 | 36 | 2022 |
| Houston Astros vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 69 | 32–37 | 34 | 2019 |
| Athletics vs. Los Angeles Angels | 68 | 34–34 | 33 | 2021 |
| Los Angeles Angels vs. Texas Rangers | 65 | 37–28 | 42 | 2021 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Los Angeles Angels | 62 | 38–24 | 33 | 2017 |
| New York Mets vs. Pittsburgh Pirates | 61 | 19–41–1 | 26 | 2009 |
| Chicago Cubs vs. Houston Astros | 60 | 33–27 | 30 | 2011 |
| Baltimore Orioles vs. Toronto Blue Jays | 60 | 27–33 | 32 | 2021 |
| Houston Astros vs. Los Angeles Dodgers | 58 | 30–28 | 28 | 2026 |
| Houston Astros vs. New York Mets | 57 | 32–25 | 28 | 1997 |
| Houston Astros vs. San Diego Padres | 57 | 28–29 | 27 | 2002 |
| Los Angeles Dodgers vs. Washington Nationals | 54 | 30–24 | 31 | 2023 |
| Cleveland Guardians vs. Texas Rangers | 53 | 24–29 | 26 | 2016 |
| Minnesota Twins vs. Texas Rangers | 52 | 31–21 | 27 | 2026 |
| Atlanta Braves vs. Detroit Wolverines | 51 | 22–27–2 | 18 | 1888 |
| Athletics vs. Seattle Mariners | 51 | 26–25 | 28 | 2023 |
| Los Angeles Angels vs. Seattle Mariners | 51 | 20–31 | 30 | 2025 |
| Houston Astros vs. Philadelphia Phillies | 50 | 30–20 | 20 | 2024 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates vs. San Diego Padres | 50 | 30–20 | 24 | 2026 |