Belt Holders
Get belt alerts
The MLB Belt · rivalry

New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays

42Belt meetings
20Yankees wins
22Blue Jays wins
19Title changes

New York Yankees and Toronto Blue Jays have met 42 times with the MLB belt on the line, from July 1, 1985 to June 14, 2026. The belt changed hands in 19 of those games. Toronto Blue Jays lead the belt series 22–20.

Belt gameDateResult
16,040Jul 1, 1985New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 4–1Title change
16,041Jul 2, 1985New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 5–3Defense
16,042Jul 3, 1985Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 3–2Title change
16,204Jun 27, 1986Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 14–7Defense
16,205Jun 28, 1986Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 7–4Defense
16,206Jun 29, 1986Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–3Defense
16,569Aug 9, 1988Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–3Defense
16,570Aug 10, 1988Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 5–0Defense
16,571Aug 11, 1988Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–5Defense
17,858Sep 6, 1996New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 4–3Title change
17,859Sep 7, 1996Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 3–2Title change
17,860Sep 8, 1996Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 4–2Defense
17,864Sep 13, 1996New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 4–1Title change
17,865Sep 14, 1996New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 3–1Defense
17,866Sep 15, 1996Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 3–1Title change
17,867Sep 16, 1996New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 10–0Title change
18,255May 28, 1999New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 10–6Defense
18,256May 29, 1999New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 8–3Defense
18,257May 30, 1999New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 8–3Defense
19,014Sep 8, 2003New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 9–3Defense
20,026Sep 15, 2009Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 10–4Title change
20,027Sep 16, 2009New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 5–4Title change
20,531Sep 19, 2012New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 4–2Title change
20,532Sep 19, 2012New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 2–1Defense
20,533Sep 20, 2012New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 10–7Defense
20,822Jul 25, 2014New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 6–4Title change
20,823Jul 26, 2014Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–4Title change
20,824Jul 27, 2014Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 5–4Defense
21,680Aug 8, 2019New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 12–6Defense
21,681Aug 9, 2019Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 8–2Title change
21,682Aug 10, 2019Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 5–4Defense
21,683Aug 11, 2019New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 1–0Title change
21,949Sep 6, 2021Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 8–0Defense
21,950Sep 7, 2021Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 5–1Defense
21,951Sep 8, 2021Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–3Defense
21,952Sep 9, 2021Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–4Defense
22,171Apr 21, 2023Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 6–1Title change
22,172Apr 22, 2023New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 3–2Title change
22,173Apr 23, 2023Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 5–1Title change
22,707Jun 12, 2026Toronto Blue Jays beat New York Yankees 8–5Title change
22,708Jun 13, 2026New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 3–1Title change
22,709Jun 14, 2026New York Yankees beat Toronto Blue Jays 8–3Defense

Compare these two → · All rivalries →

Know the second a belt changes hands

One email per title change. Nothing else.