| 2026 | Milwaukee Brewers 103–59 | Minnesota Twins 77–85 | 19th of 30 |
| 2025 | Milwaukee Brewers 97–65 | Chicago White Sox 60–102 | 29th of 30 |
| 2024 | Los Angeles Dodgers 98–64 | Chicago White Sox 41–121 | 30th of 30 |
| 2023 | Atlanta Braves 104–58 | San Diego Padres 82–80 | 15th of 30 |
| 2022 | Los Angeles Dodgers 111–51 | San Francisco Giants 81–81 | 15th of 30 |
| 2021 | San Francisco Giants 107–55 | Houston Astros 95–67 | 4th of 30 |
| 2020 | Los Angeles Dodgers 43–17 | Cincinnati Reds 31–29 | 13th of 30 |
| 2019 | Houston Astros 107–55 | Chicago White Sox 72–89 | 20th of 30 |
| 2018 | Boston Red Sox 108–54 | Cleveland Indians 91–71 | 8th of 30 |
| 2017 | Los Angeles Dodgers 104–58 | Philadelphia Phillies 66–96 | 28th of 30 |
| 2016 | Chicago Cubs 103–58–1 | Philadelphia Phillies 71–91 | 23rd of 30 |
| 2015 | St. Louis Cardinals 100–62 | Chicago Cubs 97–65 | 3rd of 30 |
| 2014 | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim 98–64 | Washington Nationals 96–66 | 2nd of 30 |
| 2013 | St. Louis Cardinals 97–65 | Baltimore Orioles 85–77 | 14th of 30 |
| 2012 | Washington Nationals 98–64 | Oakland Athletics 94–68 | 4th of 30 |
| 2011 | Philadelphia Phillies 102–60 | Philadelphia Phillies 102–60 | 1st of 30 Same |
| 2010 | Philadelphia Phillies 97–65 | Chicago White Sox 88–74 | 11th of 30 |
| 2009 | New York Yankees 103–59 | Baltimore Orioles 64–98 | 28th of 30 |
| 2008 | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim 100–62 | Houston Astros 86–75 | 11th of 30 |
| 2007 | Cleveland Indians 96–66 | Seattle Mariners 88–74 | 9th of 30 |
| 2006 | New York Mets 97–65 | Oakland Athletics 93–69 | 5th of 30 |
| 2005 | St. Louis Cardinals 100–62 | Chicago White Sox 99–63 | 2nd of 30 |
| 2004 | St. Louis Cardinals 105–57 | Houston Astros 92–70 | 6th of 30 |
| 2003 | Atlanta Braves 101–61 | Tampa Bay Devil Rays 63–99 | 29th of 30 |
| 2002 | New York Yankees 103–58 | St. Louis Cardinals 97–65 | 6th of 30 |
| 2001 | Seattle Mariners 116–46 | Pittsburgh Pirates 62–100 | 29th of 30 |
| 2000 | San Francisco Giants 97–65 | Detroit Tigers 79–83 | 18th of 30 |
| 1999 | Atlanta Braves 103–59 | Chicago White Sox 75–86–1 | 18th of 30 |
| 1998 | New York Yankees 114–48 | Minnesota Twins 70–92 | 24th of 30 |
| 1997 | Atlanta Braves 101–61 | Toronto Blue Jays 76–86 | 20th of 28 |
| 1996 | Cleveland Indians 99–62 | Boston Red Sox 85–77 | 11th of 28 |
| 1995 | Cleveland Indians 100–44 | Baltimore Orioles 71–73 | 13th of 28 |
| 1994 | Montreal Expos 74–40 | Minnesota Twins 53–60 | 16th of 28 |
| 1993 | Atlanta Braves 104–58 | Atlanta Braves 104–58 | 1st of 28 Same |
| 1992 | Atlanta Braves 98–64 | Houston Astros 81–81 | 13th of 26 |
| 1991 | Pittsburgh Pirates 98–64 | Houston Astros 65–97 | 25th of 26 |
| 1990 | Oakland Athletics 103–59 | Boston Red Sox 88–74 | 6th of 26 |
| 1989 | Oakland Athletics 99–63 | Chicago Cubs 93–69 | 2nd of 26 |
| 1988 | Oakland Athletics 104–58 | Oakland Athletics 104–58 | 1st of 26 Same |
| 1987 | Detroit Tigers 98–64 | Boston Red Sox 78–84 | 15th of 26 |
| 1986 | New York Mets 108–54 | Oakland Athletics 76–86 | 16th of 26 |
| 1985 | St. Louis Cardinals 101–61 | Oakland Athletics 77–85 | 17th of 26 |
| 1984 | Detroit Tigers 104–58 | Chicago Cubs 96–65 | 2nd of 26 |
| 1983 | Chicago White Sox 99–63 | Pittsburgh Pirates 84–78 | 11th of 26 |
| 1982 | Milwaukee Brewers 95–67–1 | St. Louis Cardinals 92–70 | 4th of 26 |
| 1981 | Cincinnati Reds 66–42 | New York Mets 41–62–2 | 22nd of 26 |
| 1980 | New York Yankees 103–59 | Cincinnati Reds 89–73–1 | 8th of 26 |
| 1979 | Baltimore Orioles 102–57 | New York Mets 63–99–1 | 24th of 26 |
| 1978 | New York Yankees 100–63 | Cincinnati Reds 92–69 | 5th of 26 |
| 1977 | Kansas City Royals 102–60 | Atlanta Braves 61–101 | 25th of 26 |
| 1976 | Cincinnati Reds 102–60 | San Diego Padres 73–89 | 19th of 24 |
| 1975 | Cincinnati Reds 108–54 | New York Mets 82–80 | 10th of 24 |
| 1974 | Los Angeles Dodgers 102–60 | Montreal Expos 79–82 | 15th of 24 |
| 1973 | Cincinnati Reds 99–63 | Los Angeles Dodgers 95–66–1 | 3rd of 24 |
| 1972 | Pittsburgh Pirates 96–59 | Philadelphia Phillies 59–97 | 23rd of 24 |
| 1971 | Baltimore Orioles 101–57 | Oakland Athletics 101–60 | 2nd of 24 |
| 1970 | Baltimore Orioles 108–54 | Oakland Athletics 89–73 | 5th of 24 |
| 1969 | Baltimore Orioles 109–53 | Kansas City Royals 69–93–1 | 18th of 24 |
| 1968 | Detroit Tigers 103–59–2 | St. Louis Cardinals 97–65 | 2nd of 20 |
| 1967 | St. Louis Cardinals 101–60 | Pittsburgh Pirates 81–81–1 | 11th of 20 |
| 1966 | Baltimore Orioles 97–63 | Houston Astros 72–90–1 | 16th of 20 |
| 1965 | Minnesota Twins 102–60 | Minnesota Twins 102–60 | 1st of 20 Same |
| 1964 | New York Yankees 99–63–2 | Chicago White Sox 98–64 | 2nd of 20 |
| 1963 | New York Yankees 104–57 | Detroit Tigers 79–83 | 12th of 20 |
| 1962 | San Francisco Giants 103–62 | Cleveland Indians 80–82 | 13th of 20 |
| 1961 | New York Yankees 109–53–1 | Cleveland Indians 78–83 | 11th of 18 |
| 1960 | New York Yankees 97–57–1 | Kansas City Athletics 58–96–1 | 16th of 16 |
| 1959 | Chicago White Sox 94–60–2 | Baltimore Orioles 74–80–1 | 10th of 16 |
| 1958 | Milwaukee Braves 92–62 | Cleveland Indians 77–76 | 7th of 16 |
| 1957 | New York Yankees 98–56 | Baltimore Orioles 76–76–2 | 9th of 16 |
| 1956 | New York Yankees 97–57 | Detroit Tigers 82–72–1 | 8th of 16 |
| 1955 | Brooklyn Dodgers 98–55–1 | Detroit Tigers 79–75 | 8th of 16 |
| 1954 | Cleveland Indians 111–43–2 | Philadelphia Athletics 51–103–2 | 16th of 16 |
| 1953 | Brooklyn Dodgers 105–49–1 | Boston Red Sox 84–69 | 6th of 16 |
| 1952 | Brooklyn Dodgers 96–57–2 | Philadelphia Athletics 79–75–1 | 8th of 16 |
| 1951 | New York Yankees 98–56 | Philadelphia Athletics 70–84 | 11th of 16 |
| 1950 | New York Yankees 98–56–1 | Philadelphia Phillies 91–63–3 | 5th of 16 |
| 1949 | New York Yankees 97–57–1 | Cincinnati Reds 62–92–2 | 13th of 16 |
| 1948 | Cleveland Indians 97–58–1 | Chicago Cubs 64–90–1 | 13th of 16 |
| 1947 | New York Yankees 97–57–1 | Chicago Cubs 69–85–1 | 12th of 16 |
| 1946 | Boston Red Sox 104–50–2 | Boston Braves 81–72–1 | 7th of 16 |
| 1945 | Chicago Cubs 98–56–1 | New York Giants 78–74–2 | 9th of 16 |
| 1944 | St. Louis Cardinals 105–49–3 | St. Louis Browns 89–65 | 3rd of 16 |
| 1943 | St. Louis Cardinals 105–49–3 | Detroit Tigers 78–76–1 | 9th of 16 |
| 1942 | St. Louis Cardinals 106–48–2 | Cleveland Indians 75–79–2 | 8th of 16 |
| 1941 | New York Yankees 101–53–2 | Philadelphia Athletics 64–90 | 14th of 16 |
| 1940 | Cincinnati Reds 100–53–2 | Cleveland Indians 89–65–1 | 3rd of 16 |
| 1939 | New York Yankees 106–45–1 | Detroit Tigers 81–73–1 | 9th of 16 |
| 1938 | New York Yankees 99–53–5 | Detroit Tigers 84–70–1 | 8th of 16 |
| 1937 | New York Yankees 103–52–2 | Detroit Tigers 89–65–1 | 4th of 16 |
| 1936 | New York Yankees 102–51–2 | Washington Senators 82–71 | 7th of 16 |
| 1935 | Chicago Cubs 100–54 | Cleveland Indians 82–71–3 | 7th of 16 |
| 1934 | Detroit Tigers 101–53 | Cleveland Indians 85–69 | 6th of 16 |
| 1933 | Washington Senators 99–53–1 | New York Yankees 91–59–2 | 2nd of 16 |
| 1932 | New York Yankees 108–47–1 | Detroit Tigers 76–76–1 | 9th of 16 |
| 1931 | Philadelphia Athletics 107–45–1 | New York Yankees 94–59–2 | 3rd of 16 |
| 1930 | Philadelphia Athletics 102–52 | Washington Senators 94–60 | 2nd of 16 |
| 1929 | Philadelphia Athletics 104–46–1 | Philadelphia Athletics 104–46–1 | 1st of 16 Same |
| 1928 | New York Yankees 101–53 | New York Yankees 101–53 | 1st of 16 Same |
| 1927 | New York Yankees 110–44–1 | St. Louis Browns 59–94–2 | 14th of 16 |
| 1926 | New York Yankees 91–63–1 | Chicago White Sox 81–72–2 | 9th of 16 |
| 1925 | Washington Senators 96–55–1 | Boston Red Sox 47–105 | 16th of 16 |
| 1924 | New York Giants 94–60 | Boston Red Sox 68–87–2 | 11th of 16 |
| 1923 | New York Yankees 98–54 | Washington Senators 75–78–2 | 10th of 16 |
| 1922 | New York Yankees 94–60 | St. Louis Browns 93–61 | 2nd of 16 |
| 1921 | New York Yankees 98–55 | St. Louis Browns 81–73 | 6th of 16 |
| 1920 | Cleveland Indians 98–56 | St. Louis Browns 76–77–1 | 8th of 16 |
| 1919 | Cincinnati Reds 96–44 | Detroit Tigers 80–60 | 6th of 16 |
| 1918 | Chicago Cubs 84–45–2 | Washington Senators 72–56–2 | 5th of 16 |
| 1917 | Chicago White Sox 100–54–2 | Cleveland Indians 88–66–2 | 5th of 16 |
| 1916 | Brooklyn Robins 94–60–2 | St. Louis Browns 79–75–4 | 9th of 16 |
| 1915 | Boston Red Sox 101–50–4 | Philadelphia Phillies 90–62–1 | 4th of 16 |
| 1914 | Philadelphia Athletics 99–53–6 | Philadelphia Phillies 74–80 | 10th of 16 |
| 1913 | New York Giants 101–51–4 | Boston Braves 69–82–3 | 10th of 16 |
| 1912 | Boston Red Sox 105–47–2 | Boston Braves 52–101–2 | 15th of 16 |
| 1911 | Philadelphia Athletics 101–50–1 | Boston Rustlers 44–107–5 | 15th of 16 |
| 1910 | Chicago Cubs 104–50 | Philadelphia Phillies 78–75–4 | 8th of 16 |
| 1909 | Pittsburgh Pirates 111–42–1 | Chicago Cubs 104–49–2 | 2nd of 16 |
| 1908 | Chicago Cubs 99–55–4 | Detroit Tigers 90–63–1 | 4th of 16 |
| 1907 | Chicago Cubs 107–45–3 | St. Louis Browns 69–83–3 | 10th of 16 |
| 1906 | Chicago Cubs 116–36–3 | Chicago Cubs 116–36–3 | 1st of 16 Same |
| 1905 | New York Giants 105–48–2 | Brooklyn Superbas 48–104–3 | 16th of 16 |
| 1904 | New York Giants 106–47–5 | Pittsburgh Pirates 87–66–3 | 8th of 16 |
| 1903 | Boston Americans 91–47–3 | Cincinnati Reds 74–65–2 | 8th of 16 |
| 1902 | Pittsburgh Pirates 103–36–3 | New York Giants 48–90–3 | 16th of 16 |
| 1901 | Pittsburgh Pirates 90–49–1 | St. Louis Cardinals 76–64–2 | 8th of 16 |
| 1900 | Brooklyn Superbas 81–54–6 | Brooklyn Superbas 81–54–6 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1899 | Brooklyn Superbas 99–47–2 | Brooklyn Superbas 99–47–2 | 1st of 12 Same |
| 1898 | Boston Beaneaters 102–47–3 | Chicago Orphans 86–64–2 | 4th of 12 |
| 1897 | Boston Beaneaters 93–39–3 | Washington Senators (1892–99) 61–71–3 | 7th of 12 |
| 1896 | Baltimore Orioles (1892–99) 90–39–3 | New York Giants 64–67–2 | 7th of 12 |
| 1895 | Baltimore Orioles (1892–99) 87–43–2 | Louisville Colonels 35–96–2 | 12th of 12 |
| 1894 | Baltimore Orioles (1892–99) 89–39–1 | Cincinnati Reds 56–76–2 | 9th of 12 |
| 1893 | Boston Beaneaters 86–43–2 | Cincinnati Reds 65–63–3 | 7th of 12 |
| 1892 | Boston Beaneaters 102–48–2 | New York Giants 71–80–2 | 8th of 12 |
| 1891 | Boston Beaneaters 87–51–2 | Philadelphia Phillies 68–69–1 | 4th of 8 |
| 1890 | Brooklyn Bridegrooms 86–43 | Brooklyn Bridegrooms 86–43 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1889 | New York Giants 83–43–5 | New York Giants 83–43–5 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1888 | New York Giants 84–47–7 | Philadelphia Quakers 70–61–1 | 3rd of 8 |
| 1887 | Detroit Wolverines 79–45–3 | Philadelphia Quakers 75–48–5 | 2nd of 8 |
| 1886 | Chicago White Stockings 90–34–2 | Philadelphia Quakers 71–43–5 | 4th of 8 |
| 1885 | Chicago White Stockings 87–25–1 | New York Giants 85–27 | 2nd of 8 |
| 1884 | Providence Grays 84–28–2 | Buffalo Bisons 64–47–4 | 3rd of 8 |
| 1883 | Boston Beaneaters 63–35 | Boston Beaneaters 63–35 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1882 | Chicago White Stockings 55–29 | Chicago White Stockings 55–29 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1881 | Chicago White Stockings 56–28 | Providence Grays 47–37–1 | 2nd of 8 |
| 1880 | Chicago White Stockings 67–17–2 | Boston Red Caps 40–44–2 | 6th of 8 |
| 1879 | Providence Grays 59–25–1 | Providence Grays 59–25–1 | 1st of 8 Same |
| 1878 | Boston Red Caps 41–19 | Cincinnati Reds (1876–80) 37–23–1 | 2nd of 6 |
| 1877 | Boston Red Caps 42–18–1 | Boston Red Caps 42–18–1 | 1st of 6 Same |
| 1876 | Chicago White Stockings 52–14 | St. Louis Brown Stockings 45–19 | 2nd of 8 |