New York City FC

1. 11th reign · New York City FCBeat Philadelphia Union 1–0 · lost to Inter Miami
   Nov 23, 2025 – Nov 29, 20256 days · 0 def.
2. 10th reign · New York City FCBeat Orlando City 2–0 · lost to D.C. United
   Sep 20, 2023 – Oct 7, 202317 days · 2 def.
3. 9th reign · New York City FCBeat CF Montréal 3–1 · lost to Philadelphia Union
   Oct 23, 2022 – Oct 30, 20227 days · 0 def.
4. 8th reign · New York City FCBeat New England Revolution 4–2 · lost to Columbus Crew
   Jul 9, 2022 – Aug 6, 202228 days · 4 def.
5. 7th reign · New York City FCBeat Portland Timbers 2–1 · lost to LA Galaxy
   Dec 11, 2021 – Feb 27, 202278 days · 0 def.
6. 6th reign · New York City FCBeat Philadelphia Union 4–2 · lost to Portland Timbers
   Jun 29, 2019 – Jul 7, 20198 days · 1 def.
7. 5th reign · New York City FCBeat FC Dallas 3–1 · lost to New York Red Bulls
   Apr 29, 2018 – May 5, 20186 days · 0 def.
8. 4th reign · New York City FCBeat Chicago Fire 2–1 · lost to Toronto FC
   Jul 22, 2017 – Jul 30, 20178 days · 0 def.
9. 3rd reign · New York City FCBeat Montreal Impact 3–1 · lost to New York Red Bulls
   Jul 17, 2016 – Jul 24, 20167 days · 0 def.
10. 2nd reign · New York City FCBeat D.C. United 3–1 · lost to LA Galaxy
    Aug 13, 2015 – Aug 23, 201510 days · 1 def.
11. 1st reign · New York City FCBeat Toronto FC 2–0 · lost to New York Red Bulls
    Jun 20, 2015 – Jun 28, 20158 days · 0 def.

Belt games by season