Belt Holders
Get belt alerts

What if?

23 famous title changes, replayed the other way

We took famous NFL title changes, flipped the result, and replayed every game since through the same rules. Sometimes the belt finds its way home within days. Sometimes it never does.

November 5, 1939 · 1939

What if New York Giants had won?

Real result: Detroit Lions beat New York Giants 18–14 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 22, 1940, 322 days later, after 1 reign that never happened.

The alternate belt: Packers

December 9, 1934 · 1934

What if Chicago Bears had won?

Real result: New York Giants beat Chicago Bears 30–13 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 29, 1935, 294 days later, after 1 reign that never happened.

The alternate belt: Packers

December 13, 1998 · 1998

What if Denver Broncos had won?

Real result: New York Giants beat Denver Broncos 20–16 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by November 28, 1999, 350 days later, after 9 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Dolphins → Falcons → Broncos → Dolphins → Bills → Raiders → Dolphins → Bills → Jets

December 18, 2011 · 2011

What if Green Bay Packers had won?

Real result: Kansas City Chiefs beat Green Bay Packers 19–14 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by January 20, 2013, 399 days later, after 10 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Giants → Cowboys → Seahawks → Rams → Dolphins → Colts → Patriots → 49ers → Seahawks → Falcons

November 20, 1921 · 1921

What if Akron Pros had won?

Real result: Dayton Triangles beat Akron Pros 3–0 · the game

History snaps back fast: the belt is back on its real path by December 11, 1921, 21 days later, after 1 reign that never happened.

The alternate belt: Bulldogs

December 13, 1942 · 1942

What if Chicago Bears had won?

Real result: Washington Redskins beat Chicago Bears 14–6 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by November 21, 1943, 343 days later.

The alternate belt: Commanders

November 16, 1930 · 1930

What if Green Bay Packers had won?

Real result: Chicago Cardinals beat Green Bay Packers 13–6 · the game

History snaps back fast: the belt is back on its real path by December 7, 1930, 21 days later, after 3 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Giants → Stapletons → Packers

January 11, 2020 · 2019

What if Baltimore Ravens had won?

Real result: Tennessee Titans beat Baltimore Ravens 28–12 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 28, 2020, 261 days later.

The alternate belt: Chiefs

January 19, 2020 · 2019

What if Tennessee Titans had won?

Real result: Kansas City Chiefs beat Tennessee Titans 35–24 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by January 3, 2021, 350 days later, after 3 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Steelers → Commanders → Seahawks

January 9, 2021 · 2020

What if Seattle Seahawks had won?

Real result: Los Angeles Rams beat Seattle Seahawks 30–20 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 29, 2022, 628 days later, after 11 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Titans → Jets → Falcons → Panthers → Patriots → Colts → Raiders → Bengals → Rams → Bills → Dolphins

January 16, 2021 · 2020

What if Los Angeles Rams had won?

Real result: Green Bay Packers beat Los Angeles Rams 32–18 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 26, 2021, 253 days later.

The alternate belt: Cardinals

January 24, 2021 · 2020

What if Green Bay Packers had won?

Real result: Tampa Bay Buccaneers beat Green Bay Packers 31–26 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by September 29, 2022, 613 days later, after 12 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Saints → Panthers → Cowboys → Broncos → Eagles → Giants → Dolphins → Titans → Bengals → Rams → Bills → Dolphins

January 29, 2023 · 2022

What if Cincinnati Bengals had won?

Real result: Kansas City Chiefs beat Cincinnati Bengals 23–20 · the game

It takes a while: the belt is back on its real path by February 11, 2024, 378 days later, after 15 reigns that never happened.

The alternate belt: Browns → Steelers → Texans → Falcons → Commanders → Giants → Jets → Chargers → Lions → Packers → Giants → Saints

January 15, 2024 · 2023

What if Pittsburgh Steelers had won?

Real result: Buffalo Bills beat Pittsburgh Steelers 31–17 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Pittsburgh Steelers, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Colts → Jaguars → Bears → Commanders → Steelers → Browns → Broncos → Chargers

January 21, 2024 · 2023

What if Buffalo Bills had won?

Real result: Kansas City Chiefs beat Buffalo Bills 27–24 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Pittsburgh Steelers, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Ravens → Browns → Chargers → Ravens → Eagles → Commanders → Eagles → Broncos

November 30, 2025 · 2025

What if Los Angeles Rams had won?

Real result: Carolina Panthers beat Los Angeles Rams 31–28 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Pittsburgh Steelers, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Seahawks → Commanders → Colts → Steelers

December 14, 2025 · 2025

What if Carolina Panthers had won?

Real result: New Orleans Saints beat Carolina Panthers 20–17 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Pittsburgh Steelers, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Seahawks → Commanders → Colts → Steelers

January 4, 2026 · 2025

What if New Orleans Saints had won?

Real result: Atlanta Falcons beat New Orleans Saints 19–17 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Chicago Bears, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Lions → Bills → Patriots → Bears

September 13, 2026 · 2026

What if Atlanta Falcons had won?

Real result: Pittsburgh Steelers beat Atlanta Falcons 20–13 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Chicago Bears, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Panthers → Browns → Jets → Patriots → Bears

September 20, 2026 · 2026

What if Pittsburgh Steelers had won?

Real result: New England Patriots beat Pittsburgh Steelers 20–3 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Chicago Bears, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Browns → Jets → Patriots → Bears

September 27, 2026 · 2026

What if New England Patriots had won?

Real result: Jacksonville Jaguars beat New England Patriots 35–6 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Chicago Bears, not New York Giants.

The alternate belt: Bears

October 18, 2026 · 2026

What if Jacksonville Jaguars had won?

Real result: Houston Texans beat Jacksonville Jaguars 34–31 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Jacksonville Jaguars, not New York Giants.

October 25, 2026 · 2026

What if Houston Texans had won?

Real result: New York Giants beat Houston Texans 27–21 · the game

The belt never finds its way back. Today it would belong to Houston Texans, not New York Giants.

Know the second a belt changes hands

One email per title change, or one a week with every belt in it. Nothing else.

Or follow every belt at once: the belt network feed (RSS) · the weekly digest · every belt game on your calendar (one subscription, all leagues and the college belts).